best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
- arpthark
- Posts: 3812
- Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:25 pm
- Location: Southeastern Connecticut
- Has thanked: 913 times
- Been thanked: 1051 times
- Contact:
best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
Any recommendations? I have been using Brasso but it has been taking forever and takes a lot of elbow grease, and it doesn't seem to work super well on NS. Thanks!
Blake
Bean Hill Brass
Bean Hill Brass
- arpthark
- Posts: 3812
- Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:25 pm
- Location: Southeastern Connecticut
- Has thanked: 913 times
- Been thanked: 1051 times
- Contact:
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
I use that for heavily tarnished silver. I wasn't aware it would work on brass. I'll give it a shot.
Blake
Bean Hill Brass
Bean Hill Brass
- Tubajug
- Posts: 738
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 10:27 am
- Location: Nebraska
- Has thanked: 221 times
- Been thanked: 191 times
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
Jordan
King 2341 with Holton Monster Eb Bell
King/Conn Eb Frankentuba
Pan AmeriConn BBb Helicon
Yamaha YBB-103
"No one else is placed exactly as we are in our opportune human orbits."
King 2341 with Holton Monster Eb Bell
King/Conn Eb Frankentuba
Pan AmeriConn BBb Helicon
Yamaha YBB-103
"No one else is placed exactly as we are in our opportune human orbits."
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
Flitz original works well for me on my raw brass sousaphone bell.
As amateur as they come...I know just enough to be dangerous.
Meinl-Weston 20
Holton Medium Eb 3+1
Holton Collegiate Sousas in Eb and BBb
40s York Bell Front Euphonium
Schiller Elite Euphonium
Blessing Artist Marching Baritone
Yamaha YSL-352 Trombone
Meinl-Weston 20
Holton Medium Eb 3+1
Holton Collegiate Sousas in Eb and BBb
40s York Bell Front Euphonium
Schiller Elite Euphonium
Blessing Artist Marching Baritone
Yamaha YSL-352 Trombone
- Rick Denney
- Resident Genius
- Posts: 1032
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:24 am
- Has thanked: 57 times
- Been thanked: 335 times
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
Wenol.
Rick "like Simicrome but cheaper and better with brass" Denney
Rick "like Simicrome but cheaper and better with brass" Denney
- bloke
- Mid South Music
- Posts: 19046
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:55 am
- Location: western Tennessee - near Memphis
- Has thanked: 3770 times
- Been thanked: 4029 times
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
...this (depending on the size of the job), not so much:arphark wrote:it has been taking forever and takes a lot of elbow grease
- arpthark
- Posts: 3812
- Joined: Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:25 pm
- Location: Southeastern Connecticut
- Has thanked: 913 times
- Been thanked: 1051 times
- Contact:
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
I have a 1/6 hp buffer, but ain't no way I'm doing a whole tooba with that.
Maybe there'll be a bigger one in my barn, some day...
Blake
Bean Hill Brass
Bean Hill Brass
- Rick Denney
- Resident Genius
- Posts: 1032
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:24 am
- Has thanked: 57 times
- Been thanked: 335 times
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
Let's understand what's happening here. The first step is to remove tarnish, and the second step is to polish the metal. For silver-plated instruments, we want to remove tarnish but not do any significant polishing. A buffer, even using the finest rouge (that red waxy cake that Joe showed) will burn through silverplate in a flash. It takes a lot of skill and feel to know how much power buffing is safe for silver, and in my view amateurs should avoid it. Wenol (and similar) on a rag will remove tarnish effectively, and usually provides an extremely mild polish to shine it up with nearly no removal, when applied by hand using a rag.
On brass, stuff like Wenol will remove oxidation and shine up the brass if the brass has a polished surface already, but if the brass has lost its polish it will benefit from buffing, and that's where the power buffer helps.
But power buffers, like all power tools, are dangerous. They work by removing (literally grinding it away) the part of the metal that isn't shine. A powerful buffer can take what you are buffing out of your hands and throw it at the floor before you even realize it happened. And it can wear down an edge and round it over in 2 or 3 seconds, removing material you can never get back, if that edge is important. There are techniques that minimize these risks, and skills that minimize them further. I've buffed a lot of metal, only some of it on tubas, for many years and there's no way I'm bringing my silver-plated, 28-pound, 44" tall, enormously expensive hand-hammered Hirsbrunner to a power buffer. But I didn't have any reluctance to push my under-a-grand Giardinelli/B&S against a power buffer.
I note that the power buffer that Bloke uses is a good deal more powerful than the one he pictured, at least the last time I saw his shop. His was belt driven with what looked like a 2- or 3-HP motor. It can tie even big tuba parts in knots easily if the operator gets crosswise with it. The Grizzly he pictured isn't on their web site, but the ones that are have a 1-HP motor (or less). The one he pictured has a nice magnetic switch. (Looking at the shaft extenders gives me an idea for an easy lathe project, by the way. My current buffer is a 1-HP motor that I'm using as a bench motor with a tapered buff arbor, but as is usually the case the buffing wheel is too close to the motor. Easy to fix.)
Rick "Wenol on a rag for routine shining up and tarnish removal" Denney
On brass, stuff like Wenol will remove oxidation and shine up the brass if the brass has a polished surface already, but if the brass has lost its polish it will benefit from buffing, and that's where the power buffer helps.
But power buffers, like all power tools, are dangerous. They work by removing (literally grinding it away) the part of the metal that isn't shine. A powerful buffer can take what you are buffing out of your hands and throw it at the floor before you even realize it happened. And it can wear down an edge and round it over in 2 or 3 seconds, removing material you can never get back, if that edge is important. There are techniques that minimize these risks, and skills that minimize them further. I've buffed a lot of metal, only some of it on tubas, for many years and there's no way I'm bringing my silver-plated, 28-pound, 44" tall, enormously expensive hand-hammered Hirsbrunner to a power buffer. But I didn't have any reluctance to push my under-a-grand Giardinelli/B&S against a power buffer.
I note that the power buffer that Bloke uses is a good deal more powerful than the one he pictured, at least the last time I saw his shop. His was belt driven with what looked like a 2- or 3-HP motor. It can tie even big tuba parts in knots easily if the operator gets crosswise with it. The Grizzly he pictured isn't on their web site, but the ones that are have a 1-HP motor (or less). The one he pictured has a nice magnetic switch. (Looking at the shaft extenders gives me an idea for an easy lathe project, by the way. My current buffer is a 1-HP motor that I'm using as a bench motor with a tapered buff arbor, but as is usually the case the buffing wheel is too close to the motor. Easy to fix.)
Rick "Wenol on a rag for routine shining up and tarnish removal" Denney
- bloke
- Mid South Music
- Posts: 19046
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:55 am
- Location: western Tennessee - near Memphis
- Has thanked: 3770 times
- Been thanked: 4029 times
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
If I use a power buffer on silver plating I usually don't put much of anything on the wheel as far as abrasive material - even keeping the amount of fine rouge dust on the wheel to a minimum, and that keeps me pretty safe.
Gold plating doesn't visit buffing machines here at blokeplace... at least not admittedly in writing on a public forum.
The topic title - though - is things to use to polish nonferrous base metals, yes?
I have two or three fractional horse machines, and a couple of multihorse machines. My most powerful multihorse machine is one that I set up the belt tension based on balance - rather than bolt or spring tension or anything like that. I have the motor gravity balanced at a particular point whereby if I start pushing too hard - or if the wheel grabs a smock or something like that, the belt is going to slip past the pulley. I have no idea whether OSHA would approve, but I approve, and I'm the only person who I allow to use it.
Gold plating doesn't visit buffing machines here at blokeplace... at least not admittedly in writing on a public forum.
The topic title - though - is things to use to polish nonferrous base metals, yes?
I have two or three fractional horse machines, and a couple of multihorse machines. My most powerful multihorse machine is one that I set up the belt tension based on balance - rather than bolt or spring tension or anything like that. I have the motor gravity balanced at a particular point whereby if I start pushing too hard - or if the wheel grabs a smock or something like that, the belt is going to slip past the pulley. I have no idea whether OSHA would approve, but I approve, and I'm the only person who I allow to use it.
- bloke
- Mid South Music
- Posts: 19046
- Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2020 8:55 am
- Location: western Tennessee - near Memphis
- Has thanked: 3770 times
- Been thanked: 4029 times
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
I guess (??) I should own some sort of product like that.
When I really want something that I can put on a rag that's sort of wet-ish (to polish non-ferrous metals like brass, bronze, nickel-brass, etc.), I put a tiny amount of lacquer thinner in a dish, crumble up some tripoli (from a bar of it), and mix them together.
Tripoli - though - is so greasy that I usually just run a rag through the tripoli.
If I actually want to "polish" something (shiny) beyond that, I run a rag through a bar of jeweler's rouge.
eh?
bloke "I'm a southerner, so maybe these tacks are way too hillbilly-ish..."
When I really want something that I can put on a rag that's sort of wet-ish (to polish non-ferrous metals like brass, bronze, nickel-brass, etc.), I put a tiny amount of lacquer thinner in a dish, crumble up some tripoli (from a bar of it), and mix them together.
Tripoli - though - is so greasy that I usually just run a rag through the tripoli.
If I actually want to "polish" something (shiny) beyond that, I run a rag through a bar of jeweler's rouge.
eh?
bloke "I'm a southerner, so maybe these tacks are way too hillbilly-ish..."
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
I just remember that when I was a freshman in college several centuries ago, the ROTC members in my dorm used to use dilute sulfuric acid on their brass uniform buttons. It was very effective, very quick, and involved virtually no physical "polishing" effort.
Gary Merrill
Amati Oval Euph (DE 104, Euph J, J6 euph)
1924 Buescher 3-valve Eb tuba (with std US receiver), Kelly 25
Amati Oval Euph (DE 104, Euph J, J6 euph)
1924 Buescher 3-valve Eb tuba (with std US receiver), Kelly 25
- LeMark
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2833
- Joined: Wed Aug 12, 2020 8:03 am
- Location: Arlington TX
- Has thanked: 77 times
- Been thanked: 819 times
Re: best raw brass/raw nickel-silver polish?
ghmerrill wrote: ↑Tue Dec 26, 2023 2:57 pm I just remember that when I was a freshman in college several centuries ago, the ROTC members in my dorm used to use dilute sulfuric acid on their brass uniform buttons. It was very effective, very quick, and involved virtually no physical "polishing" effort.
Welcome to Tuba Forum @ghmerrill (Gary)!!
Yep, I'm Mark