Page 3 of 4

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 8:25 am
by TheDoctor
Inkin wrote: Tue Nov 03, 2026 4:11 pm If you guys expect Sean or Farah's interest in Tubenet to be anything more than just a source of income off the ads, I think you're going to be disappointed...
There was tension about the plethora of ads for a while before the “social justice” takeover of it, and if you called them out, they’d have an incredibly mature and coherent rebuttal. :eyes:

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:38 am
by Schlepporello
Colby Fahrenbacher wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:52 am Again, the circumstances and/or justification for destruction of shared information is irrelevant. The destruction of that information itself is a huge loss, whether it was caused by a moderator or a poster.
Get over it.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:54 am
by dp
Colby Fahrenbacher wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:52 am Again, the circumstances and/or justification for destruction of shared information is irrelevant. The destruction of that information itself is a huge loss, whether it was caused by a moderator or a poster.
meh... shipt happens, write a book

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 11:14 am
by russiantuba
Colby Fahrenbacher wrote: Wed Nov 04, 2026 8:52 pm As Nemo said, my comment wasn't about whether anyone had the right to have their posts removed or if it was justified or not.

Simply that it is a shame that so much information was destroyed.
Much of the information rests with those people who posted it. Oral history and tradition have been part of music since before time periods that our music history textbooks cover. The information is repopulating here. Telling people
Colby Fahrenbacher wrote: "I found our conversations tiresome
is not a good method to entice the sharing of the information and to have cordial discussions.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:26 pm
by bort2.0
I wonder how AI tools be leveraged to pull and retain all of the brain dump information on a message board covering 20 plus years?

Ignore all of the opinion stuff, and just record the facts and stories and information that can be carried forward.

I guess all my old posts are still on there. Haven't really thought about it. I do post their every once in awhile if I'm trying to sell something, but even that has been a little while now.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 2:38 pm
by donn
UncleBeer wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 7:53 am
Colby Fahrenbacher wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:52 am Again, the circumstances and/or justification for destruction of shared information is irrelevant.

To you.
Well, irrelevant to me or anyone who might benefit from that information.

It seems to me I've seen something like that here, too - some user gets a rage on and deletes many or all past posts. What is it, about tuba players?

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:06 pm
by bloke
Here's a picture of Gumby.

Let's please do our best to not let anything happen to these contributions - in consideration of those who will come after us, and footnote this site - gathering material for the composition of their tuba-related dissertations towards the completion of their terminal performance degrees.

Image

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:07 pm
by MiBrassFS
Hee, hee!

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:39 pm
by Inkin
bort2.0 wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:26 pm I wonder how AI tools be leveraged to pull and retain all of the brain dump information on a message board covering 20 plus years?
This is actually something AI is really good at. It isn't that much different than scraping for web search engines. It literally just starts at the top sight and follows all the links and stores all the information and then processes it. The difference is just what you feed the information into.

When you ask ChatGPT (for example) tuba related questions, you don't really see it cite tubenet. It pulls from Reddit and from here though reasonably effectively. Like if you ask it who Lee Stofer is, you'll see it use Lee's webpage and TubaForum.net along with a couple business aggregators and Kelly mouthpieces. If you ask it who Dan Schultz is, it uses Dan's website and here, even though Dan has posted heavily on tubenet for 20+ years and never here.
bort2.0 wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 1:26 pm I do post their every once in awhile if I'm trying to sell something, but even that has been a little while now.
Dude, you're #1. Heavy is the head that wears the crown!

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:41 pm
by UncleBeer
donn wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 2:38 pm It seems to me I've seen something like that here, too - some user gets a rage on and deletes many or all past posts.
Seen any mod witch hunts about "hate speech" here? No? :huh:

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 7:09 am
by Colby Fahrenbacher
Schlepporello wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:38 am
Colby Fahrenbacher wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:52 am Again, the circumstances and/or justification for destruction of shared information is irrelevant. The destruction of that information itself is a huge loss, whether it was caused by a moderator or a poster.
Get over it.
The same could be said about everyone who keeps bitching about Tubenet here. It happened, it's done, and bitching about it changes nothing. The only productive conversations surrounding this have been the people discussing AI, archives, etc.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 7:20 am
by russiantuba
Don’t waste Colby’s time—I sure am according to him—his words.

Time to check the moon phases since a full moon or new moon seems to summon him. Seems like the old site would be a great place for him.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:17 am
by UncleBeer
Colby Fahrenbacher wrote: Fri Nov 06, 2026 7:09 am The only productive conversations surrounding this have been the people discussing AI, archives, etc.

64564.jpeg
64564.jpeg (22.34 KiB) Viewed 1486 times

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:52 pm
by splat
poomshanka wrote: Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:23 pm
arpthark wrote: Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:02 pm You can archive websites on the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine: https://web.archive.org/

Some of TubeNet is archived, but a lot isn't.
Already been way deep in there, and other places, when I was exploring a proof of concept. Now it's a matter of getting in touch with the Chishams and seeing if they're interested.

...Dave

Do it!

The internet is a big place and tubas take up too little of it. I feel like I found my people (as a big time lurker) in like 1999 in high school when i found the old bbs. (people then were heaps nicer than they are today, going by current conversations!)

Very happy to help if you need a hand.

I love tuba, and I love tuba players in person - and I imagine all the keyboard warriors here and there are probably all just flute players trying to make tuba players look bad 😘

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 9:17 am
by bloke
My phone protects me from that site and won't go there, but my laptop will go there.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:16 pm
by poomshanka
splat wrote: Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:52 pm Do it!

The internet is a big place and tubas take up too little of it. I feel like I found my people (as a big time lurker) in like 1999 in high school when i found the old bbs. (people then were heaps nicer than they are today, going by current conversations!)

Very happy to help if you need a hand.

I love tuba, and I love tuba players in person - and I imagine all the keyboard warriors here and there are probably all just flute players trying to make tuba players look bad 😘
Thanx for the offer!

Yeah, I'm of a mind that some information is better than no information. Even if 10% of the content is lost due to various issues (kerfuffle fallout, data loss, etc.), in my book, 90% still gets you an A on your report card. Hell, I'd even be happy with a B!

Right now the problem is getting in touch with the Chishams. They're not replying to my emails, and I'm not even sure they're getting through. And my post over there asking about this stuff was the last post made to the forum, i.e. no replies from admins or anyone else.

We're all stuck behind keyboards here, but I'm imagining someone has an actual analog relationship with someone who's a stakeholder. Hoping they might reach out and at least make an introduction.

Cheers...

...Dave

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 10:47 pm
by splat
poomshanka wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:16 pm
Yeah, I'm of a mind that some information is better than no information. Even if 10% of the content is lost due to various issues (kerfuffle fallout, data loss, etc.), in my book, 90% still gets you an A on your report card. Hell, I'd even be happy with a B!
Absolutely agree - one of my university saying was "P's" gets a degrees.

I think as tuba loving internet users, one of our shared focusses should be archiving and saving a bunch of word-of-mouth knowledge that is around - from verbal anecdotes of great educators and players who may have passed on, to the written thoughts of various typing tuba players over the past 30 years or so.

It's all super interesting with different AIs and crawlers, and looking at what subject matter and sites AI is crawling to come up with its "thoughts" that are then being referenced by the rest of the world and those pesky future people... who might unearth this post in 50 years time (hi future). It would be great to make sure future tuba lovers don't lose access to current knowledge that's around, even if it's incomplete.

I've always been against burning books, pro open sourcing non-commercially confidential knowledge and most of all very pro tuba (in an amateur sense...)

Fingers crossed you can get onto someone at the old site to ask for permission. Hit me up if it happens and you need any help. Go tuba!

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 8:54 am
by gocsick
poomshanka wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:16 pm

Yeah, I'm of a mind that some information is better than no information. Even if 10% of the content is lost due to various issues (kerfuffle fallout, data loss, etc.), in my book, 90% still gets you an A on your report card. Hell, I'd even be happy with a B!

If you were in my class 70% on the final gets you an A and B is usually about 50%. That's because I always overestimate the abilities of the total engineering undergrad.. so I have to and just write hard exams and use my answers as a baseline 100%. I think that's pretty fair.. If a student heavenly my class with half of what I know about a subject.. they should get a B.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:44 am
by dp
I am unconvinced that any self-styled archivist could sift through the data bits of tubenet (or tubaforum for that matter) and prepare anything more useful than what the various search engines or a.i. stuff do with their hit-and-miss versions of intelligent reconstruction. I find the naivete of suggesting otherwise staggering (see how kind I was with my word choice?)

The effect of this thread is like a colossal troll.
Being compelled (baited?) into reading the ill-will
in the responding pages is, frankly, no complement to this site (IYKYK)
bloke wrote: Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:06 pm Let's please do our best to not let anything happen to these contributions - in consideration of those who will come after us, and footnote this site - gathering material for the composition of their tuba-related dissertations towards the completion of their terminal performance degrees.
Yes. Wiki-thinking has duped so many into believing that anything on the internet is reference-able, that we can pretend content (here, for example) either in an active web page (here, for example) or even recovered from some graveyard (cornfield) of dis-associated bits, is somehow useful to a casual reviewer or tuba-owning person, and comparable to refereed journals of yore (you know...like the old T.U.B.A. Journals, or even today's ITEA journals.) Now you can prepare an acceptable dissertation for your PhD by mining TubaForum, reddit, or Tubenet? Preposterous!

In the early years there was attributable sharing by many very credible players and pedagogues, yet as internet use became more widespread the community at large (not to exclude certain mods) became increasingly disrespectful. So that level of contributions started to lessen. Then the data removal started happening (well before the Men Wearing Dresses™ period.) After a while useful content in that old site was intentionally pulled, increasingly by author requests. And In some cases because the mods or the Chishams threw people out or otherwise just copped attitudes about them. As owners, they could do that, no idea why reactions started to get to them though. No one is obligated to share their knowledge with you if you chose to insult them, lie about them, slander them, or harrass & follow them around on social media. It was one thing when users of the sites behaved that way (Charlie K was a perfect example RiP) but it was another thing entirely when the mods and owners of that site became heavy-handed, and that was well before the Men Wearing Dresses ™ period. Again, IYKYK.

Why would ANYone want to beleaguer this b.s. five-six years later? Just walk away. Join ITEA and read their journal. Ask your teacher. Practice. Talk to other players one-on-one, my friend just bought an old horn he is SO excited to be getting it this week. Coming here afterwards I wound up squandering all that happy goodness feeling on Tubenet remembrances?
:gaah: Thanks a lot.

Re: The old site is back

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 11:25 am
by bloke
dp wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:44 am I am unconvinced that any self-styled archivist could sift through the data bits of tubenet (or tubaforum for that matter)
and prepare anything more useful than what the various search engines or a.i. stuff do with their hit-and-miss versions
of intelligent reconstruction. I find the naivete of suggesting otherwise staggering (see how kind I was with my word choice?)

The effect of this thread is like a colossal troll.
Being compelled (baited?) into reading the ill-will
in the responding pages is, frankly, no complement to this site
IYKYK
yeah, but Gumby...